Mia's Pizza & Cafe

Mia's Pizza in Ortley Beach has slowly emerged as the locals' choice for the best pizza around. Word has spread about Mia's perfect combination of cheese, sauce and crust. Its small dining room and outdoor seating area are often packed, but takeout and free delivery are available, too. If you're looking for a dynamite slice of pizza and want to avoid the boardwalk crowds, head to Mia's -- but be sure to bring cash.

See more: Lavallette-Ocean Beaches restaurants, Seaside-Toms River restaurants, Italian restaurants, Pizza restaurants