Forget about using your frequent flyer miles to get a taste of Italy -- instead, just head to the Bay Avenue Trattoria in the Highlands. Owners Joe Romanowski and Maggie Lubcke have created an eatery that resembles the trattorias of Italy with a delectable menu to match. The establishment is always bustling, so make sure to call ahead for reservations. Succulent offerings range from sandwiches and salads to pasta and seafood, plus homemade desserts. Bring a bottle of wine (or two) and enjoy a fine Italian meal without leaving Eastern Standard Time.

See more: Atlantic Highlands-Highlands restaurants, Middletown Area restaurants, Italian restaurants